Colgate vs American Prediction, Picks & Odds | 21 Jan 2026

College Basketball Betting Preview: Colgate vs American

The Colgate Raiders square off against the American Eagles, with tip-off scheduled for 19:00 on Wednesday, January 21.

Our betting prediction is American to get the better of Colgate and we think that the odds of -112 represents an attractive wager on the Moneyline.

If you're picking American, don’t place that bet just yet — secure the latest BetMGM promo code and check out our comprehensive review for key insights first.

Colgate Raiders won their previous game which was at home. It was a 95-76 triumph against Bucknell Bison.

American Eagles got the win in their last game. A 78-67 triumph occurred on the road when meeting Army Black Knights.

Head-to-Head Statistics

Colgate had the edge in the most recent matchup between these teams. They recorded a 64-62 win over American. The past 10 games H2H record shows that both teams have five wins.

NCAAB	Overall	PF	PA	N. Pts	Home	Away	Strk
American	11-8	1458	1372	86	9-2	2-6	2W
Colgate	10-8	1370	1353	17	5-3	5-5	2W

View Full Standings

Colgate vs American Prediction & Picks

We cover the essential Colgate vs American betting angles, featuring our main match prediction, correct score guidance and a carefully crafted bet builder.

Game Prediction

There are plenty of reasons to support the pick that American will win this college showdown. Therefore, we’re heading to the Moneyline where you can get an attractive -112.

We’re always on top of team news and when combined with recent form, it helps us uncover the best value. Our college basketball handicappers also take a data-led approach, using key stats to back every pick.

Key Colgate vs American stats:

• American have won 8 of their last 10 games at home.
• American have won 16 of their last 20 games at home.
• American have won 2 consecutive games.
• Colgate have lost 12 of their last 20 games on the road.

American Moneyline Probability

The best betting apps make it a 52.9% chance that our pick is settled as a winner. Taking all factors into consideration, our cappers think there’s a stronger chance of success and have a probability interval between 55-60%. It’s why we think it’s worth placing this college basketball bet.

American can be backed in different ways and you might find the odds more attractive when you check out the Point Spread or the Result & Both Teams to Score lines.

Check our complete list of betting promo codes, free bet deals and the latest welcome bonuses before wagering.

Our Game Prediction

American Moneyline @ -112 Bet Now

BetMGM Promo Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Get Bonus T&C apply. Gamble responsibly 18+

Disclosure: This preview contains affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. T&Cs apply. We only recommend licensed and regulated operators. See our Editorial Policy. Pick odds and lines reflect the price available at the time of publication (23:57, 20 January 2026). Live market odds are updated regularly and may differ. 18+ (or legal age) | Gamble Responsibly.

Correct Score Prediction

Colgate 69 - 74 American

There’s the chance to back American in lots of different ways and this includes predicting the correct winning score. We’ll go for a 74-69 victory in their favor.

Colgate vs American Odds

The odds and lines are updated on a frequent basis. You might therefore find that they are different to the ones listed for the above betting predictions.

If you want to bet on American, then Moneyline odds of -112 are on offer, although Colgate are a -108 chance. According to the top sportsbooks, the home team have an implied probability of 53%.

There is a spread of 1.5 and total points has a line of 149.5. The advantage of the Totals is that you only have to choose from one of two options. There’s the chance to back Under 149.5 at -110.

If you’re betting on college basketball, it’s a good idea to visit the best sportsbooks and browse the wide range of game lines and team props available. You’ll have the option to place wagers both pre-game and in-game.

Moneyline

Colgate

-108

American

-112

Point Spread

Colgate +1.5

-115

American -1.5

-105

Total Points

Under 149.5

-110

Over 149.5

-110

If you have a view on Total Points, Three-Pointers, Assists, Double-Doubles or Triple-Doubles, then the player prop betting could be up your street. It’s a great way of wagering on individual performance.

It’s good to consider all wagering options when it comes to college basketball and micro betting can be an exciting way to get involved in the action. When everything goes in-game, consider whether the next shot will be a Two or a Three-pointer.

Latest regular season and playoff games stats.

Colgate Stats

American Stats

Moneyline

• 6 wins and 4 defeats in the last 10 games
• 5 wins and 5 defeats in the last 10 games on the road

Moneyline

• 6 wins and 4 defeats in the last 10 games
• 8 wins and 2 defeats in the last 10 home games

Point Spread

• +1.5 Betting Line: Have covered the spread in 7 of the last 10 games
• +1.5 Betting Line on the Road: Have covered the spread in 6 of the last 10 games on the road

Point Spread

• -1.5 Betting Line: Have covered the spread in 6 of the last 10 games
• -1.5 Betting Line at Home: Have covered the spread in 8 of the last 10 home games

Total Points

• Game Totals: An average of 151.80 pts in the previous 10 games
• Game Totals on the Road: An average of 154.90 pts in the previous 10 games on the road
• Over 150.5: Covered in 5 of the previous 10 games
• Over 150.5 on the Road: Covered in 4 of the previous 10 games on the road
• Team Totals: Have scored an average of 76.10 pts and allowed 75.70 pts in the last 10 games
• Team Totals on the Road: Have scored an average of 75.30 pts and allowed 79.60 pts in the last 10 games on the road

Total Points

• Game Totals: An average of 144.30 pts in the previous 10 games
• Game Totals at Home: An average of 145.00 pts in the previous 10 home games
• Over 150.5: Covered in 3 of the previous 10 games
• Over 150.5 at Home: Covered in 5 of the previous 10 home games
• Team Totals: Have scored an average of 71.30 pts and allowed 73.00 pts in the last 10 games
• Team Totals at Home: Have scored an average of 82.40 pts and allowed 62.60 pts in the last 10 home games

NCAAB Table Select Season 2025/20262024/20252023/20242022/20232021/20222020/20212019/2020

Patriot League	Overall	PF	PA	N. Pts	Home	Away	Strk
Navy	13-6	1382	1223	159	8-2	5-4	1W
American	11-8	1458	1372	86	9-2	2-6	2W
Colgate	10-8	1370	1353	17	5-3	5-5	2W
Lehigh	8-12	1461	1511	-50	5-4	3-8	1W
Holy Cross	8-12	1322	1456	-134	5-3	3-9	1L
Boston University	7-12	1440	1455	-15	5-4	2-8	2L
Army	7-12	1429	1498	-69	4-7	3-5	5L
Bucknell	6-13	1239	1453	-214	4-4	2-9	1L
Loyola Maryland	6-14	1504	1542	-38	4-5	2-9	1L
Lafayette	5-14	1329	1439	-110	4-5	1-9	1W

• Overall = Overall Wins-Losses
• PF = Total Points For
• PA = Total Points Against
• N. Pts = Point Differential
• Home = Home Record
• Away = Away Record
• Strk = Current Streak

Top Basketball Pages